All joking aside, there is no such thing as an ugly american girl doll. Today I will go through some dolls that I have witnessed people call ugly. I will list their names, their release year, and their time period if they're historical.
1. Addy Walker
1993
1864

I just wanted to be blunt, I thought Addy was ugly when I was first into AG. Then I seen her at the AG Place in Atlanta, and I thought so no more. In 6th grade, my friend and I were picking American girl books at the school library. I got Felicity's and she chose Samantha. Later, after school we were on the phone and she called numerous dolls ugly. ( most of the examples on this list are straight from her mouth). She called Addy ugly, and I said " I'm still gonna try to check out her books" (never got to, out class got banned from the library) she then said "YOU ARE????" and I don't mean she yelled, I mean she was shocked.
2. Josefina Montoya
1997
1824

If you have read my post under the "Collectors you have met in person/talked to on the phone" thread, then you know what I'm about to say. My friend, who I will call Berry from now on, (same friend in the above example) literally said I shit you not "she looks dirty". There are no words.
3. Molly McIntyre
1986
1944
Sorry this is so blurry.
Berry was looking through Molly's cookbook in the school library and said out of nowhere SHE 'S UGLY! Her reasons- Glasses. Um, Berry, you and I had glasses at the time. sucks to be her, I'm rocking contacts now.
4. Kaya'aton'my
2002
1764

Berry didn't like her because of her closed-mouth smile. I think it makes her look calm and serene. Anyway, her smile isn't just a stylistic choice. It is accurate to her culture. It was considered rude to smile open mouthed, they believed that you looked mad, like an animal baring it's teeth. I would like to see a variation on the Kaya mold, with an open smile for use on other dolls.
5. Ivy Ling
2007
1974

Ivy is a lovely doll, but Berry disagreed. So what was Ivy's offense, you ask? Looking like a pig. Once again, I shit you not.
6. Marie-Grace&Cecile
2011
1853

Berry was "picky" to say the least. She didn't dislike 1, no she went all the way. She disliked both. Marie-Grace and Cecile were put on trial and were found guilty of: Having an ugly face,and having hazel eyes when she was black. Also being "historically inaccurate" as in a white girl and a black girl being friends before civil rights.
Please take pleasure in that you never had to deal with Berry.

If memory serves, this was released in the Spring 2011 wave, where the historicals (most of them) got new outfits. This will be for Kirsten. It's not her time period, I know, but Kirsten shines in historicals dresses. With BeForever approaching like a freight train, this is number 1.
This way released in May 2014 *checks date* HOLY SHIT IT'S THE LAST DAY OF JULY SCHOOL STARTS IN 3 WEEKS! Anyway, this will be for everyone, most likely Claira because this outfit washes out dolls with lighter skin. See #27 modeling above? She looks like a stick of mozzarella.
A little late to the party on this one, bu better late than never. I think everyone will look good in this one. No clue when this first came out, but it's pretty recent.
Okay this one is a maybe. Really I only want the long sleeved T-shirt and the sneakers. If I do get it I'll probably give the rest to my mom or sell it on the 'Bay (Ebay). This is hella expensive (48$) ( not really, if were talking AG-Brand,I'm just cheap)
you can never have to many cats.
But this post isn't about Pinkie Pie!!! It's about Fluttershy! Reasons why Fluttershy is my favorite pony:



Let me say, I DO NOT like The Little Mermaid.
I do like Pocahontas, the movie and the doll. The hair on Pocahontas is ever-so-slightly more coarse than on Ariel. I think she is true to the movie character. If I had 1 complaint, add the white bead at the tip of the necklace. It will help to weigh it down. As you can see in the picture, it tends to swivel. Pocahontas does have a hint of pink eye shadow, and they should nix that too. 8.5 for accuracy
I like The Princess and The Frog and I like Tiana.
I didn't like Tangled. Go ahead.Bite Me. The hair quality is lovely, however I have had my Rapunzel for 9 months and her hair is very dry. even braid spray and a Downy Dunk wont help. Yes her hair has been kept down but she mostly sits on a shelf. Her hair reaches the floor and goes no further. Like with Mulan, her face needs to be wider, though I think she has more charisma and character than the Mulan doll. Also her freckles are too dark to be accurate. I doubt many little girls knew Rapunzel had them before owning the doll. 9 for accuracy
I liked Brave , but it was far from the best of Pixar. this doll comes with a mass of VERY crispy curls. A good wash is recommended. However the hair quality itself is awful. It frizzes on the ends with minimal brushing and styling. I recently curled the hair on mine. One day I will re-root her with better hair. As for color, its not much better. the hair color on the doll is a Ronald McDonald-esque red while the movie character has more a nectarine color.
I liked Frozen. Not as much as Mulan, but still alot. Anna is very accurate to the movie, even if she is half bald. Speaking of hair, her hair is very soft and silky. 10 for Anna. Elsa is just as accurate. She does have some faint freckles in some scenes, but I don't mind that the dolls doesn't. Elsa has silky platinum blonde hair. When you get her, there is ALOT of crunchy gel holding down the short portion on top. I recommend putting in shampoo and letting it sit ( with the suds from the shampoo still in) for a day. Yes A DAY. 10 for Elsa.